Critique & Evaluation Form

  Entry Number _________If Pattern:  Original Pattern maker______________________

   Division ______________Name of Pattern _____________________________________

   Class _________________       Original Mold Maker _________________________________

   Total Points____________

   Ribbon Awarded_________

  Each doll is evaluated on its own merit and is not compared to other entries for this Critique

   100 – 90 Points = Blue Ribbon   89 – 80 points = Red Ribbon

       CATEGORY POSSIBLE POINTS   COMMENTS

     DESCRIPTION        POINTS  SCORED

   1EXPRESSIVE IMPACT…..20  _________________________________

   Strong Visual Impact/Emotion Evoked

   2DESIGN ORIGINALITY….20    _________________________________

   Designed own unique form or creative use

   of commercial Pattern

   3INNOVATION………………5                  ________________________________

   Something New and never seen in Form,

   Concept, Technique, or successfully solved

   a difficult problem

   4IMAGINATION……………10                  ________________________________

   Unusual degree of imagination with regard

   to portraying human condition, a plaything

   or cultural object

   5BODY DESIGN AND

           COSTUMING………………15              __________________________________

   _____Neat construction

   _____Good choice of materials

   _____Interesting / innovative use of materials

   _____Appropriate / effective in achieving overall design success

   _____Costume shows good color coordination

   _____Good scale of fabrics and trims

   _____Costume well designed

   _____Costume fits well

   6ANATOMY…15                                     __________________________________

   Choose applicable of the following two

    I   ANATOMICAL DESIGN…REALISTIC INTENT

    _____Harmonious in all elements

    _____Reflects believable human anatomy

    _____Scale and proportion are uniform

    _____All parts match in type and execution

          II   ANATOMICAL DESIGN…NON-REALISTIC INTENT

   _____ Harmonious in all elements

   _____Shows good consideration of form

   _____Whole is balanced and proportionate

   _____Shows consideration of Anatomy in abstract design

   7PAINTING OR SURFACE

     FINISH TREATMENT…15                         _______________________________

             _____Shows good use of chosen technique, 

                       No parts incomplete or problems unresolved

             _____Shows good control of chosen medium

  ADDITIONAL COMMENTS

    Please feel free to discuss your critique/evaluation score with me.

   I ask only that the doll be present at this time.

Return to Display Doll Page